Skip to primary navigation Skip to content Skip to footer
Back to Big Apple Jazz Blog

Jazzy Fun with ChatGPT and the Duke Ellington Memorial


Ellington Statue

I was wondering if ChatGPT, the latest Artificial Intelligence phenomenon, would be a useful tool for blogging about jazz subjects that I’m interested in, so I started a chat about Billie Holiday and I found out that it was an unreliable source of accurate information.  I would ask it a question like, are there any streets in New York that are named after Billie Holiday, and it came back quickly with the answer that there was one in Brooklyn next to Cafe Society (which was in Greenwich Village).  The only street sign I have seen so far was in Harlem – 139th Street and Lenox Ave.  When I asked the bot if it may be mistaken about the Brooklyn street named for Billie Holiday, it said it was mistaken and readily apologized.  I concluded that ChatGPT could be spreading false information, confidently reported and easily repeated; and who needs more of that?

Having been alive lately as well as in the past, I see a trend toward lowering standards of accuracy, and I’m trying to go the other way and share information that is trustworthy or at least decently reported.  I topped this blog entry with a photo of the Duke Ellington statue that graces the traffic circle at the Northeast corner of Central Park: 110th Street and 5th Ave.  I’m going to have a conversation with ChatGPT about it and see what we can learn.  I believe in second chances.

(My part of the dialogue is in bold):

Where can I go to see a statue of Duke Ellington in NYC?

You can see a statue of Duke Ellington in NYC at Duke Ellington Circle, located at the intersection of Fifth Avenue, 110th Street, and Central Park North in Manhattan. The statue is a tribute to the famous jazz composer, pianist, and bandleader Duke Ellington, who lived nearby and frequently performed at the nearby Cotton Club in the Harlem neighborhood. The statue was created by sculptor Robert Graham and was unveiled in 1997. It depicts Duke Ellington seated on a bench with a piano keyboard and music notes on the side.

I have a couple of questions about that, I hope you don’t mind?

Of course not! Please feel free to ask any questions you may have.

I have a photo of that Duke Ellington statue and the man is standing bolt upright next to a baby grand piano. Is it possible that Robert Graham created a different statue of Duke Ellington in a seated position?

I apologize for the confusion in my previous response. You are correct that the Duke Ellington statue in NYC is not seated, but rather standing next to a baby grand piano. The statue was commissioned by the Duke Ellington Memorial Fund and was unveiled in 1997 in Duke Ellington Circle, as I mentioned before. The statue was created by sculptor Robert Graham and stands approximately 25 feet tall. I apologize for any confusion my previous response may have caused.

No problem, we all make mistakes. Can you tell me what those unclothed figures supporting the piano and the Duke represent?

Certainly! The Duke Ellington statue in NYC features three unclothed figures supporting the baby grand piano and Duke Ellington himself. According to the sculptor Robert Graham, these figures represent the three artistic influences on Duke Ellington’s music: African, European, and American.

The figure at the bottom represents African influence and is depicted as a man with his arms and legs outstretched. The middle figure represents European influence and is depicted as a woman with her arms raised and holding a book, which represents the intellectual and formal aspects of European culture. The figure at the top represents American influence and is depicted as a woman with her arms outstretched, holding a microphone and a musical score, which represents the influence of American popular culture and jazz on Duke Ellington’s music.

Together, these figures symbolize the diverse cultural influences that shaped Duke Ellington’s music and contributed to his unique sound and style.

That sounds interesting but after checking the photo of the statue in question, I don’t see what you described at all. Could there be another statue of Duke Ellington that you are remarking about?

I apologize again for the confusion in my previous responses. You are correct that the Duke Ellington statue in NYC, created by Robert Graham, does not feature the three unclothed figures supporting the piano and Duke Ellington himself. I was mistaken and described a different statue of Duke Ellington.

To answer your previous question, the statue features Duke Ellington standing next to a baby grand piano, with his right hand resting on the keyboard and his left hand holding a music score. The statue is made of bronze and stands on a granite pedestal with Duke Ellington’s name and the years of his birth and death inscribed on it.

Again, I apologize for any confusion my previous responses may have caused.

But there are several naked women included in this statue, do you have any information about these figures?

I apologize again for the confusion. To answer your latest question, you are correct that the Duke Ellington statue in NYC created by Robert Graham does feature several naked female figures. The statue is titled “Duke Ellington Memorial” and was unveiled in 1997 at Duke Ellington Circle.

The statue features Duke Ellington standing next to a baby grand piano, which is supported by three female figures, who are depicted as partially clothed and partially naked. The female figures represent the different styles of dance that Duke Ellington incorporated into his music, including ballet, modern dance, and jazz dance.

There is also a fourth female figure, fully naked, located on the opposite side of the piano. This figure represents the “creative muse” that inspired Duke Ellington’s music.

The statue is meant to celebrate Duke Ellington’s contributions to music and the arts, as well as the diverse cultural influences that shaped his music. Again, I apologize for any confusion my previous responses may have caused, and I hope this information helps clarify the features of the Duke Ellington statue in NYC.

I may be mistaken but I count nine figures: 3 groups of 3 women.

I apologize for the mistake in my previous response. You are correct that the Duke Ellington statue in NYC created by Robert Graham features nine female figures, not four. The statue is titled “Duke Ellington Memorial” and was unveiled in 1997 at Duke Ellington Circle.

The statue depicts Duke Ellington standing next to a baby grand piano, which is supported by three female figures, who are partially clothed and partially naked. These figures represent the different styles of dance that Duke Ellington incorporated into his music, including ballet, modern dance, and jazz dance.

In addition to the three figures supporting the piano, there are six more female figures located on the opposite side of the piano, also partially clothed and partially naked. These figures represent the musical influences on Duke Ellington’s work, including Latin music, spirituals, and blues.

Again, I apologize for any confusion my previous responses may have caused, and I hope this information helps clarify the features of the Duke Ellington statue in NYC.

 (Obligatory NY snarky condescending ending):
I hope I get an A on my paper about the Duke Ellington Statue. Thanks.

You’re welcome! I’m glad that I could help with your research. I’m sure that you will do great on your paper, and if you have any more questions, don’t hesitate to ask. Good luck!

 

 

If you want to see Billie Holiday Place and the Duke Ellington Memorial, please join me on a Private Tour of Harlem jazz sites.

Peace,

Gordon Polatnick
Top Cat, Big Apple Jazz Tours

 

P.S.
This is what Wikipedia had to say about the sculpture:
The Duke Ellington Memorial by Robert Graham is installed at Duke Ellington Circle in Manhattan, New York City, New York. The monument depicts Duke Ellington at a piano, supported by three columns depicting three caryatids each, known as his nine muses. It was cast in 1997 and dedicated on July 1 of that year.  Pianist Bobby Short conceived of the memorial in 1979; it was the first statue erected in Ellington’s honor in the country.

This is what Robert Graham’s website says about it: 

Dedicated on July 1, 1997, Duke Ellington Memorial was commissioned [by] the Duke Ellington Memorial Fund as a gift to the City of New York.

The Memorial is a pulpit-like form that stands 30 feet, on three tall columns. A[t] the top of each column stand three female figures that represent the muses. With their arms raised, the nine muses hold aloft a circular platform, bearing an 8-foot high standing figure of Duke Ellington beside a piano.

The figure of Duke Ellington was molded in clay at 32 inches in height. The muse figure was molded in clay at 26 inches in height. The figure[s] were scanned and enlarged in foam to 8 feet and 5 feet respectively. The figures were cast in bronze. The piano, platform, and the columns were fabricated from bronze sheets and all the elements were welded and patinaed. The interior of the dome platform was gilded in gold. With the exception of casting the figures, which were done at Mussi Artworks Foundry in Berkeley, all work on this project was completed at Robert Graham Studio in Venice, California.

Duke Ellington Memorial is installed at Duke Ellington Circle (Fifth Avenue at 110th Street) in Central Park, New York City.

 

Lastly, this is an entry with more to consider from the NYC Parks and Rec. website:

Duke Ellington Statue

This text is part of Parks’ Historical Signs Project and can be found posted within the park.

This monumental sculpture by Robert Graham (1938-2008) was dedicated on July 1, 1997 at the circle defining the northeast corner of Central Park at 110th Street and Fifth Avenue, and honors American jazz pianist, composer and orchestra leader Edward “Duke” Kennedy Ellington (1899-1974).

Born in Washington, D. C., Ellington was the son of a butler and “a young woman so proper she would countenance neither birth control or lipstick.” Early piano lessons had little influence on the later musical genius, and he was “at first too lazy, and later too superstitious to learn to read music.” Yet in 1916 Ellington made his first professional appearance, and by 1918 had formed a band.

Ellington’s first attempt to break into the New York jazz scene in 1922 met with failure, but he returned the following year, and found regular work at the Hollywood Club at West 49th Street and Broadway in Manhattan. The pace of performing quickened, and Ellington’s band recorded Black and Tan Fantasy in 1927. The band took on several accomplished musicians, including saxophonist Johnny Hodges, and the enriched orchestra had a regular engagement at Harlem’s famed Cotton Club from 1927 to 1931. Ellington’s contributions as a composer of great chromatic range and complexity established his band as the premier jazz orchestra of that generation, surpassing even that of Fletcher Henderson.

The remainder of his life was spent composing and performing, and his various bands toured extensively in America and abroad. Several of his short works, such as Mood Indigo, In a Sentimental Mood, and Sophisticated Lady are acknowledged classics, and Ellington also composed more extensive concert pieces, which he performed at venues such as Carnegie Hall and the Cathedral of St. John the Divine.

In 1979 singer, pianist and jazz interpreter Bobby Short formed a committee whose intent was to commission a major permanent sculpture honoring Ellington. The Duke Ellington Memorial Fund selected contemporary artist Robert Graham to create this sculptural tribute.

Los Angeles based artist Robert Graham was well-known also for his monument to boxer Joe Louis in Detroit, Michigan, his Olympic Gateway in Los Angeles, California, and for his tableau at the Franklin Delano Roosevelt Monument in Washington, D. C. His artistic conception for this monument depicts an upright Duke beside his piano, supported by a matrix of female nudes the artist likened to the ancient Greek muses. The muses rest atop three columns which support a gilded bronze dome.

Though the sculpture is representational, it is meant to evoke the intangible qualities of Ellington’s lasting musical artistry, and to serve as a bridge between elegant Fifth Avenue, pastoral Central Park and the Harlem community where “the Duke” achieved much of his fame. When the sculpture was unveiled in 1997, no less than three New York City mayors—Edward I. Koch, David N. Dinkins and Rudolph W. Giuliani—delivered remarks, and musical entertainment included such esteemed performers as Mr. Short and trumpeter Wynton Marsalis.

  • Customizable

We’ll design your private jazz tour based on your tastes and our extensive knowledge of musicians, clubs and speakeasies throughout the city.  We know what is happening nightly on and off-the-beaten-path.